It doesn’t price the general public £500,000 to coach a physician

17 July 2023

This appears unlikely to be true. About 19% of UK-trained docs who left the register or gave up their licence final yr stated they have been doing so to maneuver overseas.

Virtually half of the docs skilled within the UK later transfer to Australia or New Zealand.

Incorrect. Whereas it might price roughly this a lot to coach a senior physician, the associated fee to coach somebody till they change into a junior physician is far much less.

It prices almost half 1,000,000 kilos of our cash to coach a GP or a surgeon. At the moment, they’re free to reap the benefits of our subsidised coaching, then later transfer to Australia or New Zealand — as virtually half do — and never pay a penny again! Nadine Dorries MP, .

We tax payers pay half 1,000,000 £ to coach a physician and when they’re certified, virtually half of them from some medical faculties head to Australia or NZ. Nadine Dorries MP, .

In an article within the Each day Mail, and a tweet sharing it the next day, the previous well being minister Nadine Dorries made a number of barely totally different claims about the price of coaching docs.

Though the associated fee to public funds of coaching somebody all the way in which to their qualification as a GP or a surgeon might get near £500,000 (as Ms Dorries claimed within the Mail) the price of coaching somebody till they’re a physician (as she stated in her tweet) is far much less.

Full Truth has requested Ms Dorries for the supply of her declare within the Mail that “virtually half” of docs, GPs or surgeons who skilled within the UK later transfer to Australia or New Zealand, however we’ve got not heard again.

We’ve not been capable of finding conclusive proof on this level, however primarily based on the proof we’ve got, it seems unlikely to be true.

Politicians should use correct figures when speaking about UK public providers—and supply proof to point out this. In any other case they danger misinforming voters concerning the state of the nation, which might injury the democratic course of.

Honesty in public debate issues You may assist us take motion – and get our common free electronic mail I’m in

What does it price to coach a physician?

To be able to qualify as a physician on the most junior stage, a candidate should normally research for 5 years at medical faculty. The federal government pays a part of the associated fee for these programs, and affords a variety of various scholar loans and grants.

The Private Social Providers Analysis Unit (PSSRU) on the College of Kent produces estimates for the price of coaching totally different sorts of docs. The 2022 version of those estimates means that the entire price of coaching somebody till they end medical faculty is £244,730.

As we wrote in 2016, the cash doesn’t essentially all come from public funds, nonetheless. Some is paid by the scholars themselves, both immediately or by way of loans that the majority ultimately repay.

A authorities estimate in 2018 discovered that loans accounted for about 28% of the associated fee. If that is nonetheless true then the last word price from public cash of coaching a physician now could be round £175,000.

Even when a physician strikes overseas, they’re nonetheless purported to repay their scholar mortgage.

What about extra senior docs?

College students who’ve accomplished medical faculty are initially registered as docs of their first yr of labor. They then proceed to coach for plenty of years afterwards with a view to change into extra expert.

Throughout this era, the federal government continues to pay the price of coaching them, in addition to contributing to the wage they’re paid whereas being skilled. When PSSRU contains these prices, it estimates that the price of coaching the extra senior grades ranges between about £312,051 for a physician finishing their first yr of labor and £430,540 for a GP or £584,102 for a advisor (which incorporates surgeons).

These figures additionally embrace earlier undergraduate prices, which can have been paid partly by the scholars themselves, maybe not directly by way of loans. Medical doctors should pay tax on their salaries too, so a portion of this affordably comes again to public funds.

In brief, Ms Dorries was mistaken to say in her tweet that it prices the general public about £500,000 to coach a physician. However the approximate price of coaching a GP or a surgeon could also be “almost half 1,000,000”, as she stated in her newspaper article.

What number of UK-trained docs transfer overseas?

The declare from Ms Dorries about docs transferring overseas got here in two barely totally different kinds.

In her newspaper article, she stated that nearly half of GPs and surgeons transfer to Australia and New Zealand after qualifying. In her tweet, she stated it was virtually half of docs “from some medical faculties”.

Ms Dorries hasn’t responded to our query about precisely what she meant, and we’ve not been capable of finding the identical declare being made elsewhere.

We’ve additionally not been capable of finding knowledge displaying the proportion of UK-trained docs (or GPs or surgeons) who subsequently transfer to Australia or New Zealand (maybe damaged down by the medical faculty the place they skilled).

A tough estimate utilizing the info we’ve got means that the declare is unlikely to be true, nonetheless.

What we do know

For one factor, most UK-trained docs don’t go away their job quickly after graduating. For instance, knowledge from the Normal Medical Council exhibits that about 89% of the docs who graduated within the UK and joined the medical register in 2015 have been nonetheless registered in 2021—and never all the individuals who left the register may have moved overseas.

Certainly about 24% of all docs who left the register or gave up their licence to practise within the yr to Might 2022 stated that the primary purpose was that they wished to practise overseas. The determine for docs whose major medical qualification was from the UK was decrease, at 19%. In the identical yr, a complete of 1,284 docs stated they left to practise in Australia or New Zealand, 898 of them British nationals.

But OECD knowledge exhibits that there have sometimes been round 8,000 to 9,000 new medical graduates per yr within the UK over the previous decade.

OECD knowledge additionally exhibits that there have been 9,725 UK-trained docs working in Australia or New Zealand in 2021, which is the most recent yr for which we’ve got knowledge on each nations.

In different phrases, if it have been true that nearly half of the docs skilled within the UK moved to Australia or New Zealand, that ought so as to add a median of roughly 4,000 a yr to their mixed whole, which might be an infinite share of the UK-trained docs in these nations.

To reiterate: these figures don’t conclusively disprove Ms Dorries’ declare. We additionally don’t know what the numbers would appear to be if we centered solely on GPs or surgeons, or break up them up by medical faculty.

Nonetheless, on the face of it, it does appear unlikely that nearly half of the docs who skilled within the UK go on to maneuver to Australia or New Zealand.

Picture courtesy of UK Authorities